A Baltimore judge has dismissed three second-degree murder charges against James Edwin Barnett, 58, who is accused of setting the January 2022 fire in a vacant South Stricker Street rowhome that killed three Baltimore City firefighters and seriously injured a fourth. Barnett remains on trial on charges related to the blaze, which devastated the Baltimore firefighting community.

The fire broke out early on January 24, 2022, at 205 South Stricker Street in the Mount Clare neighborhood. Firefighters responded after a 911 call reported a fire in the vacant three-story rowhome, along with reports of people trapped inside. As crews entered the burning building, the structure partially collapsed, trapping firefighters beneath the debris. Lt. Paul Butrim, Lt. Kelsey Sadler and EMT/firefighter Kenny Lacayo died from their injuries. EMT/firefighter John McMaster survived but suffered serious injuries.

The case against Barnett relied in part on surveillance footage and forensic analysis. According to court documents, video showed Barnett entering the rear of the building late on January 23, 2022, with several flashes of light visible while he was inside. He left several minutes later, and footage subsequently showed smoke coming from the rear of the rowhome. Investigators used light-source analysis to examine the flashes and concluded they were consistent with sparks and an open flame from a butane cigarette lighter. The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives classified the fire as incendiary, meaning it was intentionally ignited.

Barnett had previously lived in the building and told investigators in 2022 that he had access to it, but he denied setting the fire. He was arrested in November 2025 after a lengthy investigation involving the ATF, Baltimore City Fire Department and Baltimore Police Department.

The judge dismissed the three second-degree murder counts after prosecutors and the defense rested their cases, ruling that the state had not presented sufficient evidence to support a conviction under the legal standard for second-degree depraved-heart murder. The ruling does not end the trial. The jury will still consider charges of second-degree arson, three counts of involuntary manslaughter and five counts of reckless endangerment. Closing arguments were scheduled for Wednesday morning, October 14, 2026.

This article was independently written by the BJL Newsroom based on reporting from FOX45 News, WBAL-TV and the Baltimore City State’s Attorney’s Office.